Skip to main content

POS migration

Moving from Toast to Square when you are paying for depth you never use.

This is usually a smaller place. A cafe, a bakery, a bar, a counter-service kitchen that was sold a full-service system and uses maybe a third of it.

The move is legitimate and it is also the one where people most often underestimate what they are giving up. Both halves are on this page.

Tell us what is happening on your floor →

The short answer

Can you switch from Toast to Square, and what does it cost you?

Yes. Toast exports menu, order, payment, item selection and modifier detail as daily files, and Square takes a bulk item import. What you give up is coursing depth, seat-level splitting and a kitchen display built into the core product. Check your Toast term first: it renews annually unless you give thirty days written notice, and early exit means paying out the remaining software subscription.


Check the term first

Before any of the rest of this matters, read your Toast order form, because the exit terms decide your timeline.

Toast’s merchant agreement runs for the initial period set out in your order and then automatically renews for successive one-year periods unless either party gives at least thirty days’ written notice of intent not to renew before the end of the current term. You can terminate before that, but the early termination fee is the remaining software subscription fees that would have been due for the rest of the term, or on a pay-as-you-go subscription a set amount for each month remaining, plus any processing fee tied to software financing.

So the first question is not what does Square do. It is when does my term end, and have I already missed the notice window. Find the date. Put the notice in writing, because a phone call to support frequently does not satisfy a contract’s own notice requirement even when the person you speak to is helpful.

If you are seven months from renewal with a meaningful payout, the correct answer is usually to plan the move for the renewal date and use the intervening months to build properly rather than to pay for the privilege of hurrying. We will schedule work around that. It delays our invoice and it is the right call.

Paying for capability you never switch on is a slow leak, not an emergency.

What you give up

Square for Restaurants has closed a lot of ground, and for counter service, cafes and bars it is frequently the better fit. It is not a like-for-like replacement for Toast in a full-service dining room, and anyone telling you otherwise is selling something.

The specific things to check against your service before you commit. Coursing and seat-level check splitting are where Toast is genuinely built for table service, and if your servers rely on them daily this move will hurt. Kitchen display is core product on Toast; on Square it is an add-on billed per device on the paid plans, so if you run several screens the saving is smaller than the headline suggests. Ingredient-level inventory on Square generally means a third-party integration on top rather than something native.

Also worth pricing honestly: the daily automated exports Toast produces. Order details, payment details, item selection details, modifier selection details, kitchen details, cash management, product mix, time entries and accounting entries, generated after your closeout hour and retrievable over FTP or a command line tool. If your accountant or your inventory system consumes those, that pipe has to be rebuilt on the Square side before cutover, not after somebody notices in month two.

The honest test is the third-of-the-system one. Open your Toast back office and list the features you touched in the last ninety days. If the list is short and none of it is coursing, seat-level splitting or multi-screen kitchen display, this move is probably right. If half of it is, stop.

What moves

The extraction side is comfortable, because Toast is good about giving data back. Menu data, order details, payment details, item selection details, modifier selection details and time entries all come out as files, either manually from Toast Web or automatically via FTP or the command line tool. That is a genuinely full picture of what you sell and how the modifiers behave.

Square takes a bulk item import covering item name, variation name, description, SKU, categories, pricing, modifier sets, inventory counts, tax information and location-specific columns, plus item types and reporting categories. The mapping between the two is manual work and there are two specific traps worth naming.

First, nested modifier sets import into Square, but the nesting relationships between them cannot be configured through the import. If your Toast menu has modifiers hanging off modifiers, that structure is rebuilt by hand. Second, Square’s reporting categories are separate from its display categories, and an item imported into several categories without a specified reporting category ends up with none, which quietly ruins your sales reports until someone notices. We set reporting categories deliberately, because getting them right is most of what makes Square’s reporting useful.

Everything that was configuration rather than data gets documented off Toast while it still runs and rebuilt: routing, day-part behavior, permissions, discount and comp rules, and receipt setup. Do this while you still have access. It is much harder to reconstruct from a spreadsheet.

Gift cards and loyalty

The liability question, again, because it is the one that gets skipped and the one that comes back.

On the way out, Toast balances live in Reports, Payments, Gift Card Balances, keyed on the 16-digit card number. That report is your record of what you owe on the last night. Pull it, keep it, and do not throw it away after the switch, because cards keep arriving for a year or more.

On the way in, Square’s official route is not self-service. You contact Square with a CSV of previously issued gift cards and balances, they upload it to your account, and you then redeem and check balances by manually entering the gift card number. Their format conditions are specific and worth getting right the first time: no header row, zero-balance cards removed, amounts in cents with no decimal point, card numbers numeric only and between 4 and 19 digits. Square also says clearly that non-Square gift cards cannot be activated or reloaded, and that it cannot guarantee every card number format will be supported.

That is the sentence that decides your plan. Old cards can be honored. They cannot be topped up. So you either replace them at the counter as customers appear, or you run the old report alongside for a year. Both are fine. Deciding in advance is what separates a tidy switch from a scene at the register on a Saturday.

Loyalty runs the same way. Toast rewards balances can be adjusted individually and exported, with no bulk update available in Toast Web, so a set of balances leaves as a spreadsheet. Square Loyalty has no self-service bulk import of reward balances either; you are looking at a support-assisted load or a deliberate reset. A reset is worth genuinely considering. Writing to your list to say the program is changing and here is something better to start you off is cheaper, cleaner, and generally received better than a silent conversion at an unfamiliar rate.

Reasons to stay

Two versions of not needing it, and they point in opposite directions.

The first: you are paying for a plan tier and add-ons you do not use, and the fix is a conversation rather than a migration. Before you move anything, list what you are billed for monthly, work out your effective processing rate from three months of statements rather than from a rate card, and take both to your current provider. Sometimes the number moves. A migration costs money and weeks, and it is a strange way to solve a billing problem you have never once raised.

The second: the depth is not the problem, the configuration is. If Toast feels heavy because the menu was built badly at launch and nobody has touched it since, moving that same badly built menu onto Square gives you a badly built menu on a system with less depth to absorb it. A health check tells you which of the two you have, and it costs a fraction of the switch.

Our manifesto puts honest value first. Before you invest in a migration, understand whether a better setup could solve the problem.

How the weeks go

Four to six weeks of work for one location, but the calendar is set by your Toast notice date rather than by the build.

First: the contract. Find the term end, find the notice window, get the exit figure in writing. Then extraction, while Toast is still fully live. Menu data and the item and modifier selection detail. Customers. The gift card balance report. The loyalty balances. A written record of routing, permissions, comp rules and day-part behavior.

Then the Square build, with reporting categories set deliberately and the modifier structure rebuilt where nesting cannot be imported. Validation against the source, your team running the test-order script with real orders, and launch early in the week after our team’s review.

The first week on this particular move usually surfaces two things: a discount or comp rule that behaved differently on Toast, and a category that reports oddly because of the reporting-category trap. Both are quick once you know to look, and the support team in your portal knows to look.

Side by side

Scroll sideways on a phone.

Toast to Square: what survives the move
Feature WhatComes across?What it takes
Menu and item data Yes, by fileToast menu and item selection exports mapped into a Square bulk import
Modifier structure PartlyModifier sets import; nesting relationships between them cannot be configured by import and are rebuilt
Reporting categories Set by handItems imported into several categories without one end up with none. This is set deliberately
Customer records Yes, by fileCSV, deduplicated on the way in
Gift card balances By request onlyToast balance report out, then a support-side load into Square. Old cards get honored, never reloaded
Loyalty balances By request, or resetNo bulk update on either side. Frequently better closed out and relaunched
Sales history NoExported as files before the account closes. Square reporting starts at launch
Automated nightly exports RebuiltIf your accountant or inventory system consumes them, that feed is replaced before cutover
Hardware NoToast hardware does not run Square. Some counter setups can start on an iPad you already own

What the migration includes

Stated in numbers, so nobody has to guess where it ends.

One fixed scope with the limits in plain numbers, so you know before you call whether your operation fits inside it. The price lives on the pricing page.

01

Full Square configuration

One location. Up to 100 items, 20 modifier groups and 100 modifier choices, categories, taxes and service settings, up to 5 staff roles, up to 2 standard integrations, and online ordering.

02

Contract and notice review

We read your Toast order form with you and identify the term end and the notice window before anything else starts, so the plan fits your date instead of fighting it.

03

Clean-source data mapping

Toast menu and item selection exports mapped into Square field by field, with reporting categories set deliberately and modifier nesting rebuilt where the import cannot carry it. Clean source means a legible export; deduplicating a cluttered menu is separate work and we flag it up front.

04

Migration and validation

Loaded, then checked back against Toast: item counts, price spot-checks, tax by category, modifier behavior and reporting categories on the twenty items you sell most.

05

Launch checklist and test-order script

A written checklist you keep, and a test-order script your team runs, ringing real orders on Square while Toast is still the system of record.

06

Launch review and portal support

Our team reviews the configuration against the checklist before it goes live, early in the week. Afterward, the support team in your portal works from the setup record, which is where the comp rule and the odd category get caught.

07

Quick-start guides, walkthroughs and a setup record

One for the people ringing orders, one for whoever changes a price at seven in the morning. The configuration is documented and handed over.

Anything past these limits is quoted before it starts, never after. Every published price is on one page.

Be honest with me

Stay on Toast if:

  • Your servers use coursing and seat-level check splitting every service. That is what Toast is built for, and giving it up to save on subscription is a trade you will resent by the second Friday.
  • You are inside the notice window with a meaningful early termination fee. Plan the move for the renewal date instead. We will hold the work for you rather than let you pay twice.
  • You run several kitchen display screens. Square bills kitchen display per device as an add-on, so the saving shrinks as screens multiply. Do that arithmetic before you decide, not after.
  • Your accountant or your inventory system feeds on Toast automated nightly exports and nobody has planned the replacement pipe. Rebuild that first or you will spend the first month exporting things by hand.
  • The real problem is that your menu was built badly at launch. Moving a bad build to a lighter system makes it worse, not cheaper. Fix the build, then decide.

Questions we get

Can I cancel Toast whenever I want?

Not without cost, in most cases. The agreement runs for the term in your order and renews for successive one-year periods unless someone gives at least thirty days written notice before the term ends. Terminating early means paying the remaining software subscription for that term, plus any financing fee attached to the software. Find your date before you plan anything else.

Will Square do everything Toast does?

No, and we would rather say so. Coursing and seat-level check splitting are where Toast is genuinely built for table service. Square bills kitchen display as a per-device add-on rather than treating it as core. Ingredient-level inventory usually means a third-party integration. For counter service, cafes and bars, none of that may matter. For a busy dining room, it will.

What happens to gift cards my customers hold?

Pull the Toast gift card balance report on the last night and keep it. Square can load a list of previously issued cards and balances through its support team, in a specific format, and you then look cards up by entering the number. Square does not activate or reload non-Square cards, so old cards are honored rather than topped up. Plan for that, in writing, before launch.

Is this worth it just to save on the monthly bill?

Sometimes, and less often than people expect. Before moving anything, list what you are billed for each month, work out your effective processing rate from three months of statements, and take both to your current provider. A migration is an expensive way to solve a billing conversation you have never had. If the numbers still favour moving after that, they favour it honestly.

How long should we allow?

Four to six weeks of work for a single location, but the calendar is usually set by your Toast notice date rather than the build. If your renewal is months away and the payout is meaningful, we will plan the launch for the renewal and use the interval to build properly. That delays our invoice and it is still what we recommend.


Find your renewal date, then talk to us.

It is the number that decides everything else about this move. Send us the order form and the last three months of statements and we will tell you whether switching, renegotiating, or leaving it alone is the better use of your money.

Platform pricing and features change; where a platform does not publish a number we say so rather than guessing.

Shop & Table connects with supported commerce platforms. Toast and Square are trademarks of their respective owners.

Your preferences

Privacy choices

Choose which optional services can run on this website. Everything optional stays off until you choose. You can change your settings at any time.

Advertising tags are not configured on this website. These settings apply to this browser on this website; platform and ordering accounts have their own choices.

Make yourself comfortable

Accessibility

Choose what makes this page comfortable. Preferences stay on this device.

Navigate this page

Keyboard shortcuts

On a Mac, Alt is the Option key. Shortcuts do not run while you’re typing in a field, or with Control or Command held.

Alt + Shift + A
Open accessibility tools
Alt + Shift + S
Navigate by page structure
Alt + Shift + ?
Show keyboard shortcuts
Alt + Shift + T
Text size: next size
Alt + Shift + C
Contrast: next level
Alt + Shift + F
Focus outline on or off
Alt + Shift + L
Highlight links on or off
Alt + Shift + H
Highlight headings on or off
Alt + Shift + M
Stop animation on or off
Alt + Shift + G
Reading guide on or off
Alt + Shift + R
Reset everything

Policies & Choices

Open Page →